关于日本医学暴行的海外伦理学争鸣

伦理学研究 ›› 2022 (3): 110-117.

关于日本医学暴行的海外伦理学争鸣

杨彦君

出版日期:2022-05-10 发布日期:2022-07-19
作者简介:杨彦君,侵华日军第七三一部队罪证陈列馆研究员,清华大学历史系博士研究生。
基金资助:
国家社会科学基金抗日战争研究专项工程“跨学科视域下细菌战罪行研究”（21KZD004）与国家社会科学基金一般项目“伯力审判新发现录音资料翻译整理与利用研究”（20BZS071）的阶段性成果

Overseas Ethical Dialogues on Japanese Medical Atrocities

YANG Yan-jun

Online:2022-05-10 Published:2022-07-19

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 进入21世纪以来,海外伦理学者围绕战时日本医学暴行何以发生,是否可以避免人体实验大屠杀,美国是否回应以及应该如何回应,生命伦理学界的伦理反思与现实期待等主题展开了国际对话,日本、新西兰、以色列、美国、德国、俄罗斯和比利时等国学者相继参与其中,展开了学术界比较鲜见的激烈争鸣。海外学者从生命伦理学视角来审视、反思和回应上述议题,展开了极富成果的交流探讨,既呈现出他们的历史认识,又体现了其对当代社会的反思与期待。然而,在对话的过程中,这些海外伦理学者少有触及跨学科视野下的新成果,理应深刻认识到战时日本的人体实验是不折不扣的医学犯罪,亟须强化事实判断和价值判断的契合度,提升伦理学与历史学的融合效果,应积极推动更多中国学者参与海外伦理学争鸣。

关键词: 人体实验, 医学暴行, 生命伦理, 当代反思

杨彦君. 关于日本医学暴行的海外伦理学争鸣[J]. 伦理学研究, 2022(3): 110-117.

YANG Yan-jun. Overseas Ethical Dialogues on Japanese Medical Atrocities[J]. Studies in Ethics, 2022(3): 110-117.

参考文献

[1] MORIOKA M.Commentary on Tsuchiya[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2000,10(6).
[2] TSUCHIYA T.Why Japanese Doctors Performed Human Experiments in China 1933-1945[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2000,10(6).
[3] NIE Jingbao.Challenges of Japanese Doctors’ Human Experimentation in China for East-Asian and Chinese Bioethics:Commentary on Tsuchiya[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2001,11(1).
[4] KAUR S.Rather than Responding to the Past,Shape the Future Instead[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[5] LEAVITT Y.Is Asian Bioethics at Fault?Commentary on Tsuchiya,Morioka,and Nie[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2001,11(1).
[6] DOERING O.Comments on Inhumanity in the Name of Medicine:Old Cases and New Voices for Responsible Medical Ethics from Japan and China[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2001,11(2).
[7] TSUCHIYA T.In the Shadow of the Past Atrocities:Research Ethics with Human Subjects in Contemporary Japan[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(3).
[8] THOMAS M.Ethical Lessons of the Failure to Bring the Japanese Doctors’ to Justice[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(3).
[9] LEAVITT F.Let’s Stop Bashing Japan:Commentary on Tsuchiya,Sass,Thomas,Nie & Tsuneishi[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(4).
[10] NIE Jingbao.Let’s Never Stop Bashing Inhumanity:A Reply to Frank Leavitt and an Appeal for Further Ethical Studies on Japanese Doctors’s Wartime Experimentation[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(5).
[11] THOMAS M.Let’s Deal With the Issue:Commentary on Leavitt[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(5).
[12] TSUCHIYA T.A Reply to Leavitt’s Commentary——Let’s Stop Bashing Japan[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(5).
[13] SASS H-M.Ambiguities in Judging Cruel Human Experimentation:Arbitrary American Responses to German and Japanese Experiments[J].Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics,2003,13(3).
[14] NIE Jingbao.The United States Cover-up of Japanese Wartime Medical Atrocities:Complicity Committed in the National Interest and Two Proposals for Contemporary Action[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2006,6(3).
[15] DEVOLDER K.U.S. Complicity and Japan’s Wartime Medical Atrocities:Time for a Response[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[16] YUDIN B.U.S. Complicity and Japan’s Atrocities:How to Respond?[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[17] MILES S H.The Diptych:Nazi and Japanese Bioscience War Crimes[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[18] AULTMAN J.When Saying Sorry Is Not Enough:Acknowledging Past Wrongs in Human Subjects Research[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[19] STROUS R D,ZIVOTOFSKY A Z.Looking to the Future from the Past:Take Home Lessons from Japanese World War II Medical Atrocities[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2015,15(6).
[20] Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No.10(Volume II)[M].Washington,D.C.:U.S. Government Printing Office,1949.
[21] 小俣和一郎.検証·人体実験―731部隊·ナチ医学[M].東京:第三文明社,2003.