美国行政伦理研究视点的变迁——以《公共行政评论》为例

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 《公共行政评论》作为美国公共行政学会会刊,反映出了行政伦理研究视点在20世纪的变迁。40—60年代,行政伦理研究从改变公共行政学的价值中立预设开始,以行政责任为关注点,从行政伦理的外部控制与内部控制研究,发展到关注行政组织、行政制度的伦理内容研究。70年代,以“社会公平与公共行政”为研究焦点形成新公共行政学派。80年代,关注对“行政伦理”立法的反思,建构“公民主义”的研究进路。90年代,研究方法与研究立场逐渐多元化,研究视阈拓展。21世纪初,批判进路的行政伦理研究继续深化发展,学者也关注行政伦理学发展过程中显现出来的一些具体问题。

关键词: 美国行政伦理, 视点变迁, 《公共行政评论》

Abstract: <Public Administration Review> is the journal of American Society for Public Administration.Its articles reflect the transfer of administrative ethics study viewpoint in 20th century.During the periods of 1940s-1960s,the research began from concern on changes of value-free assumption of public administration study.Scholars focus on administrative accountability,external controls,internal controls,administrative organization,administrative system.In 1970s,new public administration school formed and its concern is "social equality and public administration".In 1980s,reflection on administrative ethics legislation and construction of citizenship approach are the research contents.In 1990s,it appeared multiple methods and standpoint of study and the sphere of administrative ethics enlarged.At the beginning of 21st century,the critical theory of administrative ethics continued and scholars discussed some detailed problems.

Key words: American administrative ethics, viewpoint transfer, public administration review

中图分类号:

B82-051

罗蔚. 美国行政伦理研究视点的变迁——以《公共行政评论》为例[J]. 伦理学研究, 2010(1): 29-34.

LUO Wei. The transfer of American administrative ethics study viewpoint——Illustration of<public administration review>[J]. Studies in Ethics, 2010(1): 29-34.

参考文献

[1] Terry L.Cooper.The emergence of Administrative Ethics as a Field of Study in theUnited States [A].Terry L.Cooper.Handbook of Administrative Ethics[C].New York,Marcel Dekker,Inc.,2001.
[2] Finer.Administrative responsibility in democratic government[J].Public Administration Review,1941,Vol.1(3):P335-350.
[3] Levitan,D.M.The Neatrality of Public Service[J].Public Administration Review,1942,Vol.2(3):P317-323.
[4] Leys.W.A..ethics and administrative discretion[J].Public Administration Review,1943,Vol.3(1):P10-23.
[5] Caldwell,L.K.Thomas Jefferson and public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1943,Vol.3(2):P240-245.
[6] Appleby,P.H.Toward better public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1949,Vol.9(1): P93-99.
[7] Sayre,W.S.Trends for a decade in administrative value[J].Public Administration Review,1951,Vol.11(1): P1-8.
[8] Moneypenney,P.A code of ethics as means of controlling administrative conduct[J].Public Administration Review,1953,Vol.13(2):P184-187.
[9] Golembiewski,R.T.Organization as a moral problem[J].Public Administration Review,1962,Vol.22(1):P51-58.
[10] Bailey,S.K.Ethics and public service[J].Public Administration Review,1964,Vol.24(2):P234-243.
[11] Herbert J.Storing The critical link: Public administration,Responsibility,and the Public Interest[J].Public Administration Review,1964,Vol.241):P40-46.
[12] Harmon,M.M.Social equity and organizational man: motivation and organizational democracy [J].Public Administration Review,1974,Vol.34(1):P11-18.
[13] Hart,D.K.Social equity,justice and equitable administrato[J].Public Administration Review,1974,Vol.34(1):P3-11.
[14] Porter,D.O.and Portor,T.W.Social equity and fiscal federation[J].Public Administration Review,1974,Vol.34(1):P36-51.
[15] Chitwood,S.R.Social equality and Social service productivity[J].Public Administration Review,1974,Vol.34(1):P29-35.
[16] Frederickson,H.G.Introductory comments: Social equality and public administ ration[J].Public Administration Review,1974,Vol.34(1):P1-2.
[17] Foster,G.D.Law,morality and public servant[J].Public Administration Review,1981,Vol.41(1):P29-33
[18] Frederickson,H.G.The recovery of civism in public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1982,Vol.42(5):P501-508.
[19] Hart,D.K.The virtuous citizen,the honorable bureaucrat,and public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1984,Vol.44(1):P111-120
[20] Thompson,D.F.The possibility of administrative ethics[J].Public Administration Review,1985,Vol.45(6):P555-569.
[21] Richardson,W.G.and Nigro,L.G.Administrative ethics and founding thought: constitutional correctives,honor,and education[J].Public Administration Review,1987,Vol.47(3):P367-376
[22] Cooper,T.L.Hierarchy,virtue,and the practice of public administration: a perspective for normative ethics[J].Public Administration Review,1987,Vol.47(3):P320-328.
[23] Hejka Ekins,A.Teaching ethics in public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1988,Vol.48(6):P885-891.
[24] Rohr,J.A.British and American approaches to public service ethics[J].Public Administration Review,1989,Vol.49(4):P387-390
[25] Ventriss,C.Toward a public philosophy of public administration: A civic perspective of the public[J].Public Administration Review,1989,Vol.49(2):P173-179.
[26] Nigro,L.G.,&Richardson,W.G..Between citizen and administrator:administrative ethics and PAR[J].Public Administration Review,1990,Vol.50(6):P623-635.
[27] Bingham,Richard D.& Bowen,William M.“Mainstream” public administration over time: A topic content analysis of public administration review[J].Public Administration Review,1994,Vol.54(2):P204-208.
[28] James S.Bowman Ethics in government: A national survey of public administrator[J].Public Administration Review,1990,Vol.50(4):P345-353.
[29] Bowman,J.B.,Williams R.L.,Ethics in government: from a winter of despair to a spring of hope[J].Public Administration Review,1997,Vol.57(6):P517-526.
[30] Montgomery Van Wart The sources of ethical decision making for individuals in the public sector[J].Public Administration Review,1996,Vol.56(6):P525-533.
[31] Nigro,L.G.and Richardson,W.G.Between citizen and administrator: administrative ethics and PAR[J].Public Administration Review,1990,Vol.50(6):P623-635.
[32] Marini,F.The uses of literature in the exploration of public administration ethics: the example of Antigone[J].Public Administration Review,1992,Vol.52(4):P420-426.
[33] Camilla Stivers,The listening bureaucrat: responsiveness in public adminitration[J].Public Administration Review,1994,Vol.54(4):P 364-369.
[34] Camilla Stivers Settlement women and bureau man: constructing a usable past for public administration[J].Public Administration Review,1995,Vol.55(6):P522-529.
[35] Donald C.Menzel,Rediscovering the lost world of public service ethics:Do we need new ethics of public administrators?[J].Public Administration Review,1999,Vol.59(5): P443-447.
[36] James S.Bowman,Evan M.Berman,Jonathan P.West,The profession of public administration: an ethics edge in introductory textbooks? [J].Public Administration Review,2001,Vol.61(2):P194-205.
[37] Robert W.Smith,Enforcement or ethical capacity: considering the role of state ethics commissions at the millennium[J].Public Administration Review,2003,Vol.63(3):P283-295.
[38] Kalu N.Kalu,Of citizenship,virtue,and the administrative imperative: Deconstructing civic republicanism[J].Public Administration Review,2003,Vol.63(4):P418-427.
[39] Cooper,T.L.,Big questions in administrative ethics:A need for focused,collaborative effort[J].Public Administration Review,2003,Vol.64(4):P395-407.
[40] William.T.Gormley Jr.Moralists,Pragmatists,and Rogues: Bureaucrats in Modern Mysteries[J].Public Administration Review,2001,Vol.61(2):P184-193.